FOUR LAKES TASK FORCE
  • About
    • History
    • Who We Are >
      • Team Bios
    • Operations
    • Secord Dam
    • Smallwood Dam
    • Edenville Dam
    • Sanford Dam
  • Restoration Plan
  • Donate
    • Why Donate?
    • Our Donors >
      • Corporate Sponsors
      • Individual Donors
    • Four Lakes Legacy Society
  • Events
  • Documents
    • Annual Reports
    • Audited Financials
    • County Documents
    • Edenville/Wixom
    • Engineering Reports & Studies
    • Flyers & Brochures
    • Meeting Presentations
    • News Flashes
    • Newsletters
    • Publications & Partner Presentations
    • Published Statements
    • Regulatory Correspondence
    • Restoration Plan
    • Sanford
    • Secord
    • Smallwood
    • Tax Filings & Governance
  • Resources
    • Erosion Control >
      • Project Map
      • Project Permitting
      • What You Can Do
    • FOIA Request
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Lakebottom Information
    • Subscribe
    • Updates
    • Volunteer Portal
  • Special Assessment District
    • Assessment Map
    • FAQs
  • Contact

Restoration Path Forward

Feasibility Study of the Four Lakes of Gladwin County and Midland County
Read Full Study
Jump to: Outline ~ Appendix~ Acronyms List

LETTER FROM DAVE KEPLER
Dear Lake Community Members:
Working with property owners; our communities; and our counties, state and federal officials and agencies, we will bring back the lakes. That is and has been the mission of Four Lakes Task Force (FLTF) since the May 19, 2020, breach of the Boyce-owned Edenville Dam and failure of the Sanford Dam, and the federally mandated lowering of Secord and Smallwood lakes.

It has been one year since the rain and flooding that could change our region permanently. By June of 2020, FLTF had submitted a short-term plan and by September, had a more detailed, longer-term recovery plan in place. At the one-year anniversary since the dams breached, we are publishing the Four Lakes Restoration Plan – a comprehensive technical report describing our path forward to bring back the dams and recover the surrounding ecosystem that was damaged by the flooding.

FLTF assembled a world-class team of experts to develop this plan. Our conclusion, with agreement by those experts, is that restoring the lakes is feasible and necessary. A brief summary of the key points of the plan is included with this letter.
 
After years of suffering under the poor stewardship of our lakes, the worst-case scenario happened, leaving the counties, lake communities and property owners to deal with the disaster. The federal regulatory system was not designed to deal with an owner like Boyce Hydro. The state regulatory system had the issue dumped into its lap with limited information to understand Edenville Dam’s challenges. The creditors and Boyce were more focused on their interests in bankruptcy than on dealing with the situation on the ground.
 
There would have been no path to having future lakes if the counties had not stepped forward to acquire the properties and stabilize the situation on the ground, with support from the state and federal governments.

Lake restoration comes at a cost; by our estimates approximately $250 million. It will require special assessments of property owners, loans from the U.S. Department of Agriculture, and additional significant grants from the federal and state governments. And a lot of teamwork from everyone.

Yet we are fully confident implementing this plan will restore the life we knew before the May 2020 disaster and make it even better. If we all work together, we will have more robust dams, safer communities and a more sustainable future for our economy and our environment – for everyone and for all lakes.
​
On behalf of the Four Lake Task Force and the Lake Associations, I ask you to join us in this effort as we move to the next phase to restore our lakes and heal our communities.
Picture
Dave Kepler
President and Lake Property Owner 
Four Lakes Task Force
go to executive summary
 

Outline & Appendix

CHapter 1: EXecutive Summary (PG. 5)
1a. Public Sector Consultants Demographics Report
1b. Decommissioning Report for Secord, Smallwood, Edenville and Sanford Dams by The Essex Partnership
1c. Update to Hydropower Feasibility by The Essex Partnership
1d. Desktop Study - Restoration of Hydroelectric Generation at Secord, Smallwood, Edenville and Sanford Dams by The Essex Partnership
Chapter 2: Introduction and BAckground (PG. 13)
Memorandum Re. Legal Framework (FLTF Feasibility Study)
Chapter 3: County Ownership of Dams, Bottomlands and Flowage Rights (PG. 17)
3a. Covenant Deed
3b. Flowage License
3c. Recorded Order Vesting Title - Gladwin County
3d. Recorded Order Vesting Title - Midland County
Chapter 4: Future Use and Function of the Lakes (pg. 19)
4a. Sanford Lake - Economic Analysis Report by Public Sector Consultants
4b. Fishing Economic Activity by Streamside Ecological Services
Chapter 5: Lake Community Survey (Pg. 21)
Four Lakes Task Force Survey Results by PSC
​Chapter 6: Flood Management (Pg. 29)
Flood Management
Chapter 7: Dam Safety Design Criteria (Pg. 31)
7a. 2020 Planning Level Cost Memo by GEI
7b. 100-Year Floodplain Evaluation (Secord and Smallwood Dams) by GEI
7c. Secord Dam - Design Basis Report by GEI
7d. Smallwood Dam - Design Basis Report
7e. Edenville Dam - Design Basis Report
7f. Sanford Dam - Design Basis Report
7g. 100-Year Floodplain Evaluation (Secord and Smallwood Dams) Technical Memo by GEI
 Chapter 8: Environmental Restoration Planning (Pg. 59)
8a. Lake Restoration Plan
8b. Pre- and Post-Disaster Wetland Analysis by Merjent
8c. Secord Lake - Restoration Fishery Scoping Report by Streamside Ecological Services
8d. Smallwood Lake - Restoration Fishery Scoping Report
8e. Wixom Lake - Restoration Fishery Scoping Report
8f. Sanford Lake - Restoration Fishery Scoping Report

8g. Secord Lake – Initial Mussel Report by Central Michigan University, Biology Department and Institute for Great Lakes Research
8h. Smallwood Lake – Initial Mussel Report
8i. Wixom Lake – Initial Mussel Report
8.j Sanford Lake – Initial Mussel Report
8k. Phase I Archaeological Resources Investigation of the Secord Dam and Smallwood Dam Projects by Spicer Group
8l. Four Lakes Lake Level Study by Spicer Group
8m. Secord Dam - Delineation Report by Merjent
8n. Secord - Environmental Impact Map
8o. Smallwood Dam - Delineation Report
8p. Smallwood - Environmental Impact Map 
8q. Edenville Dam - Wetland Delineation Report
8r. Edenville - Environmental Impact Map
8s. State of Michigan Consent Judgment Against Boyce Hydro, Nov. 2019
8t. Sanford Dam - Wetland Delineation Report
8u. Sanford - Environmental Impact Map
​Chapter 9: Operations Excellence (Pg. 73)
Operations and Monitoring Report by The Essex Partnership
Chapter 10: Funding and Financing (Pg. 75)
No appendices
Chapter 11: Special Assessment District, Property Benefits and Affordability Analysis (Pg. 81)
No appendices
Chapter 12: Project Implementation - Risks and Conclusion (Pg. 97)
No appendices 
Chapter 13: CONCLUSION (PG. 101)
No appendices
Addendum to Chapters 10 & 11: Status and financing update
FLTF Restoration Plan Status Update
Addendum published April 7, 2022
 

Acronyms
ALICE: Asset Limited, Income Constrained and Employed
Ayres: Ayres Associates
BMP: best management practice
Boyce: Boyce Hydro Power
EAP: emergency action plan
EGLE: Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes and Energy
ER: environmental report
EWP: Emergency Watershed Protection (program)
FEMA: Federal Emergency Management Agency
FERC: Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
FIRM: flood insurance rate map
FIS: flood insurance study
FLTF: Four Lakes Task Force
FPA: Federal Power Act
GEI: GEI Consultants of Michigan
GLFC: Great Lakes Fish Commission
IDF: inflow design flood
LiDAR: Light Detection and Ranging
LOMC: letter of map change
MDHHS: Michigan Department of Health and Human Services
MDNR: Michigan Department of Natural Resources
MDSP: Model Dam Safety Program
MNFI: Michigan Natural Features Inventory
NFIP: National Flood Insurance Program
NRCS: Natural Resources Conservation Services
NREPA: Natural Resources and Environmental Protection Act
O&M: operations and maintenance
OHWM: ordinary high-water mark
OPCC: opinion of probable construction costs
Part 307: State of Michigan inland lakes of the Natural Resource and Environmental Protection Act 451 of 1994
PER: preliminary engineering report
PMF: probable maximum flood
PMP: probable maximum precipitation
PSC: Public Sector Consultants
QBS: qualifications-based selection
RCAP: Rural Communities Assistance Program
RD: rural development
SAD: Four Lakes Special Assessment District
SCADA: Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition
SESC: soil erosion and sedimentation control
SEV: state equalized value
SFHA: special flood hazard area
SGI: Spicer Group, Inc.
T&E: threatened and endangered (species)
USACE: United States Army Corps of Engineers
USBR: United States Bureau of Reclamation
USDA: United States Department of Agriculture
Appendix
CHAPTER 1
  • Public Sector Consultants Demographics Report
  • Decommissioning Report for Secord, Smallwood, Edenville and Sanford Dams by The Essex Partnership
  • Update to Hydropower Feasibility by The Essex Partnership
CHAPTER 2
  • ​Memorandum Re. Legal Framework (FLTF Feasibility Study)
CHAPTER 3
  • Covenant Deed
  • Flowage License
  • Recorded Order Vesting Title - Gladwin County
  • Recorded Order Vesting Title - Midland County
CHAPTER 4
  • Sanford Lake - Economic Analysis Report by Public Sector Consultants
  • Fishing Economic Activity by Streamside Ecological Services​
CHAPTER 5
  • Four Lakes Task Force Survey Results by PSC​
CHAPTER 6
  • Flood Management​
CHAPTER 7
  • 2020 Planning Level Cost Memo by GEI
  • 100-Year Floodplain Evaluation (Secord and Smallwood Dams) by GEI​
  • Secord Dam - Design Basis Report by GEI
  • Smallwood Dam - Design Basis Report
  • Edenville Dam - Design Basis Report
  • Sanford Dam - Design Basis Report
  • 100-Year Floodplain Evaluation (Secord and Smallwood Dams) Technical Memo by GEI​​
CHAPTER 8
  • Lake Restoration Plan
  • Pre- and Post-Disaster Wetland Analysis by Merjent
  • Secord Lake - Restoration Fishery Scoping Report by Streamside Ecological Services
  • Smallwood Lake - Restoration Fishery Scoping Report
  • Wixom Lake - Restoration Fishery Scoping Report
  • Sanford Lake - Restoration Fishery Scoping Report
  • Secord Lake – Initial Mussel Report by Central Michigan University, Biology Department and Institute for Great Lakes Research
  • Smallwood Lake – Initial Mussel Report
  • Wixom Lake – Initial Mussel Report
  • Sanford Lake – Initial Mussel Report
  • Phase I Archaeological Resources Investigation of the Secord Dam and Smallwood Dam Projects by Spicer Group
  • Four Lakes Lake Level Study by Spicer Group
  • Secord Dam - Delineation Report by Merjent
  • Secord - Environmental Impact Map
  • Smallwood Dam - Delineation Report
  • Smallwood - Environmental Impact Map 
  • Edenville Dam - Wetland Delineation Report
  • Edenville - Environmental Impact Map
  • State of Michigan Consent Judgment Against Boyce Hydro, Nov. 2019
  • Sanford Dam - Wetland Delineation Report
  • Sanford - Environmental Impact Map
CHAPTER 9
  • Operations and Monitoring Report by The Essex Partnership
CHAPTERS 10-13
No appendices
Figures
FIGURE 1: Dam Restoration Costs . 8
FIGURE 2: Funds Needed to Achieve Lower Assessment . 11
FIGURE 3: Years of Ownership . 22
FIGURE 4: Importance of Lakes 23
FIGURE 5: Confidence in Recovery 23
FIGURE 6: Selling Property . 24
FIGURE 7: Rebuilding the Dams . 24
FIGURE 8: Need for Special Assessment . 25
FIGURE 9: Paying for the Dams 26
FIGURE 10: Willingness to Pay . 27
FIGURE 11: Property Values Compared to the Assessment Amount . 27
FIGURE 12: Four Lakes Watershed 29
FIGURE 13: Map of FLTF Dams and Lakes 32
FIGURE 14: Summary of Existing and Required Spillway Discharge Capacity 34
FIGURE 15: Summary of Inflow Design Flood (1/2 PMF + Design Storm) 35
FIGURE 16: Aerial View of Secord Dam Spillway and Non-Operational Powerhouse 37
FIGURE 17: Inspection Photographs of Secord Dam . 38
FIGURE 18: Cross-Section View of Proposed Secord Dam Crest Gate Spillway . 38
FIGURE 19: Plan View of Proposed Secord Dam Auxiliary Spillway 39
FIGURE 20: Cross-Section View of Secord Dam Embankment Repairs 40
FIGURE 21: Secord Summary of Opinion of Probable Construction Costs Based on the 30 Percent Design 41
FIGURE 22: Inspection Photographs of Smallwood Dam Spillway and Powerhouse 42
FIGURE 23: Cross-Section View of Smallwood Dam Crest Gate Spillway . 43
FIGURE 24: Plan View of Smallwood Dam Auxiliary Spillway 44
FIGURE 25: Cross-Section View of Smallwood Dam Embankment Repairs 45
FIGURE 26: Smallwood Summary of Opinion of Probable Construction Costs Based on the 30 Percent Design 46
FIGURE 27: Aerial View of Edenville Dam Failure . 47
FIGURE 28: Cross-Section View of Edenville Dam Three-Bay Crest Gate Spillway . 49
FIGURE 29: Elevation View of Proposed Tobacco Spillway Three-Bay Crest Gates 49
FIGURE 30: Plan View of Edenville Dam Auxiliary Spillway Left of Tittabawassee Spillway 50
FIGURE 31: Cross-Section View of Tittabawassee Auxiliary Spillway 50
FIGURE 32: Cross-Section View Edenville Dam Left Embankment Reconstruction 51
FIGURE 33: Edenville Summary of Opinion of Probable Construction Costs Based on the 30 Percent Design 52
FIGURE 34: Aerial View of Sanford Dam Failure . 53
FIGURE 35: Plan View of Proposed Sanford Repairs . 54
FIGURE 36: Plan View of Sanford Dam Primary Spillway Upgrades 55
FIGURE 37: Cross-Section View of Sanford Dam Crest Gates . 55
FIGURE 38: Plan View of Sanford Dam Auxiliary Spillway 56
FIGURE 39: Cross-Section View of Sanford Dam Auxiliary Spillway 56
FIGURE 40: Cross-Section View Sanford Dam Right Embankment Reconstruction 57
FIGURE 41: Sanford Summary of Opinion of Probable Construction Costs Based on the 30 Percent Design . 58
FIGURE 42: Summary of Probable Costs for Each Dam Site . 58
​FIGURE 43: Donald Drive Site on Sanford Lake — Before vs. After Stabilization Project 62
FIGURE 44: Pre- and Post-Disaster Wetland and Surface Water Analysis Results for Wixom and Sanford Lakes . 64
FIGURE 45: Planning Level Assessments Without State or Federal Funding . 83
FIGURE 46: Lot Map . 84
FIGURE 47: Sample Lake Map . 84
FIGURE 48: Funds Needed to Achieve Lower Assessment . 86
FIGURE 49: Secord Front Lot Homestead and Non-Homestead Parcels 87
FIGURE 50: Secord Backlot Homestead and Non-Homestead Parcels . 87
FIGURE 51: Smallwood Lake Front Lot Homestead and Non-Homestead Parcels . 88
FIGURE 52: Smallwood Lake Backlot Homestead and Non-Homestead Parcels 88
FIGURE 53: Wixom Front Lot Homestead and Non-Homestead Parcels . 89
FIGURE 54: Wixom Backlot Homestead and Non-Homestead Parcels . 89
FIGURE 55: Sanford Lake Homestead and Non-Homestead Parcels 90
FIGURE 56: Sanford Backlot Homestead and Non-Homestead Parcels 90
FIGURE 57: Gladwin and Midland Counties’ Employment Information 91
FIGURE 58: County Housing Characteristics 92
FIGURE 59: Gladwin and Midland County Residents’ Income Ranges 92
FIGURE 60: Township Employment Information . 93
FIGURE 61: Housing Characteristics 94
FIGURE 62: Income Ranges for Townships Within the SAD . 95
FIGURE 63: Critical Factors by Lake . 97
FIGURE 64: Risk Analysis . 98
Read Full Study
About Us
Meet the board
Read our history
See our supporters
Learn More
Frequently asked questions
Special Assessment District

View documents
See updates
How to control erosion
Why we're raising money
Get Involved
Donate
Attend a meeting
Contact us
Subscribe for email updates
Volunteer portal

Ask a question • Get our emails
©2022 | Four Lakes Task Force is a US 501 (c)(3) public charity, EIN 27-4698447. 
Four Lakes Task Force
  • About
    • History
    • Who We Are >
      • Team Bios
    • Operations
    • Secord Dam
    • Smallwood Dam
    • Edenville Dam
    • Sanford Dam
  • Restoration Plan
  • Donate
    • Why Donate?
    • Our Donors >
      • Corporate Sponsors
      • Individual Donors
    • Four Lakes Legacy Society
  • Events
  • Documents
    • Annual Reports
    • Audited Financials
    • County Documents
    • Edenville/Wixom
    • Engineering Reports & Studies
    • Flyers & Brochures
    • Meeting Presentations
    • News Flashes
    • Newsletters
    • Publications & Partner Presentations
    • Published Statements
    • Regulatory Correspondence
    • Restoration Plan
    • Sanford
    • Secord
    • Smallwood
    • Tax Filings & Governance
  • Resources
    • Erosion Control >
      • Project Map
      • Project Permitting
      • What You Can Do
    • FOIA Request
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Lakebottom Information
    • Subscribe
    • Updates
    • Volunteer Portal
  • Special Assessment District
    • Assessment Map
    • FAQs
  • Contact